The Enshittification Machine

Article tag · 50 matching pages

Community governance weakened after a change of ownership | Dead Internet Theory

Dead Internet Theory: Twitter's Trust & Safety Council gave outside organizations a formal advisory route into platform policy before the 2022 ownership change. Its dissolution, followed by X's confirmation that no replacement advisory body was in place, shows how community influence can disappear even while the service itself continues operating.

Volunteer contributions monetized without corresponding contributor control | Dead Internet Theory

Dead Internet Theory: Stack Overflow shows how a knowledge base built from unpaid user contributions can become part of commercial data partnerships even though individual contributors have little control over the business decisions made around the resulting corpus.

Platform terms changed after users invest in a dependent business | Dead Internet Theory

Dead Internet Theory: Amazon's 2020 affiliate commission cuts show how a business can invest years in traffic, content, and conversion around one platform, then discover that the platform can rewrite the economics with little notice.

Shutdowns of useful products that do not meet corporate growth targets | Dead Internet Theory

Dead Internet Theory: Google Reader's 2013 shutdown shows how a product can remain useful and loved by a dedicated audience while still failing the scale and focus tests of the company that operates it.

Digital purchases redefined by licensing and continued platform access | Dead Internet Theory

Dead Internet Theory: PlayStation's 2023 Discovery-content notice showed how a digital item labeled as purchased can still depend on licensing agreements and continued storefront access. The planned removals were later canceled, but the episode exposed the dependency clearly.

The gap between user satisfaction and financial performance | Dead Internet Theory

Dead Internet Theory: Facebook's 2024 satisfaction score remained near the bottom of the social-media industry while Meta's revenue and advertising business grew sharply, showing that financial performance and user satisfaction can move on very different tracks.

Exit campaigns that fail because participants cannot coordinate departure | Dead Internet Theory

Dead Internet Theory: Quit Facebook Day in 2010 showed how difficult it is to organize a mass departure from a social network when each participant's reason to leave depends partly on whether everyone else leaves too.

Cooperatives and member ownership as alternative service incentives | Dead Internet Theory

Dead Internet Theory: Stocksy United shows how a digital marketplace can give contributors ownership, voting rights, royalties, and possible profit sharing instead of treating them only as suppliers to an investor-owned platform.

Open protocols as a way to reduce dependence on one provider | Dead Internet Theory

Dead Internet Theory: ActivityPub and Mastodon show how open protocols can let users communicate across separately operated services and move some relationships between providers, while still leaving important limits around identity, moderation, and historical content.

Conditions under which a platform can improve after a period of decline | Dead Internet Theory

Dead Internet Theory: Flickr's acquisition by SmugMug shows what platform recovery can look like when ownership, infrastructure investment, staffing, and product priorities change together rather than relying on a temporary promotion or redesign.